Can we really offer the best?
I’m not entirely sure if I’m just getting older and more cynical about how we advertise, or I have grown to be more sensitive in how we communicate events to young people, but whenever it comes to promoting a new event or trying to let everyone what’s going on in the new term I struggle to say something along the lines of “We are going to have the best time ever”. I find it more and more exhausting and honestly, I am not sure I can even promise such a thing.
So why do we have such an impulse or desire to say such a thing? What is underneath this desire to hype up what we plan? Are we trying to control something that cannot be controlled?
Trying to control the world
I was speaking to my friend Paul who is always super helpful in helping me flesh out my discontentedness in things like this, and he pointed me in the direction of Hartmut Rosa.
Rosa (2018) talks of the journey from youth to adulthood. When we are young children we learn to ride a bike, and in that process our world becomes bigger. We can now reach the park, cycle to the river or a lake, to the edges of town - I remember growing up with the freedom to cycle to nearby villages to play football with friends. As we grow up, we learn to drive, which broadens our world further to other cities and finally, with airports and planes, we are able to fly to virtually anywhere in the world!
Now think about the internet. All our friends, loved ones and not so loved ones are all a click away. Social media makes events across the world virtually attend-able. The observation that Rosa makes, is that the world is now at our fingerprints in a historically unprecedented way - that the world is now within reach. And what is within reach we want to control.
Rosa gives four dimensions of controllability:
Making the world controllable means, first, making it visible, that is, making it knowable, expanding our knowledge of what is there.
Furthermore, what is visible we then make reachable or accessible. Think of the moon landing and Columbus.
Here we bring the world under our control, by making it manageable. With technological innovations we can now manage the temperature of rooms, how light our surroundings are when night arrives.
The last dimension to bringing controllability is making it useful. What is there, what is present is instrumentalised, transformed into the material and the object of our own projections and desires. Notably in politics, where we vote for who will be the most useful: vote for us and there will be better jobs, more affordable housing, faster transportation…
The more control we have the more available, predictable and responsive the world around us becomes to our desires.
Rosa doesn’t necessarily call this bad. However, he does point out that despite this desire to control the world, there is still the uncontrollable. Life both starts and ends uncontrollably. We find ourselves in a storm or under an incredible sunset, or the northern nights. The point that Rosa makes here, is that within the uncontrollability of life and the world, something outside of us speaks. Rosa calls this encounter resonance. When we find ourselves caught up in an experience that is beyond our control, like a beautiful sunset, we resonate with nature - it is something beyond us!
When you hear your favourite song for the first time, that cannot be replicated the next ten times you play it. We long for resonance but it cannot be controlled. We try though don’t we? We can purchase a tour of Iceland to see the northern lights or go whale spotting - and companies brand themselves of offering such a uncontrollable encounter. But as Rosa points out: resonance with nature cannot be bought. The more we strive to engineer such an encounter, the less likely it will become.
The point Rosa makes is that control is helpful. But will it lead us to have meaningful, resonating experiences with what is beyond us? The answer is no. So as we grow to expect the world to be constantly available, predictable and responsive to our desires, how do we stop ourselves from projecting this desire for control on to our youth work? And what would it look like to plan in order for these more resonating experiences to happen?
Responding within youth work
I don’t think I’ve gone through all of that just to say that we can’t say “we’re going to have the best time ever” because we can’t guarantee it - even though there is a truth in the sentiment. I just want to share a few points that dive a bit deeper.
Trauma literature tells us that there is a benefit to being more descriptive. When we communicate emotionally it can become challenging for a young person who hasn’t been exposed to a positive environment to imagine what an event or space is that offers “the best” and could potentially evoke anxiety rather than excitement. It isn’t predictable and doesn’t offer any kind of containment - two things that can help regulate a young person. A more helpful way would be to simply describe what the event will hold, and leave it there. The best thing we can do is to leave the responsibility of whether something is “the best” up to the young person to decide for themselves. Trying to add these superlatives only deepens this desire for controllability over what we want for the event.
This is where we can offer something very counter cultural to young people. The young person is being told they must control all aspects of their life; their education, what job they’ll have, what stance they should have on every global topic, to be uniquely themselves but also to fit in and not stand out, how they should have a good time. The list could go on. Everything is within reach - they only need to reach out and grab it. This is where youth work can become prophetic. Brueggemann’s definition of the prophetic is “to nurture, nourish and evoke a consciousness and perception alternative to the consciousness and perception of the dominant culture around us.” If our responsibility to young people is to offer an alternative to the dominant culture around us, we must resist the temptation to follow this narrative of control, and allow young people to experience the uncontrollable in a safe environment - namely a dependable relationship that is not trying to predetermine an experience or how someone should feel. By us not having this desire to manufacture experiences we can’t offer, it allows us to respond faithfully with young people to these moments of resonance. Whether that be a poignant conversation that sparks wonder, to delight in nature, or to sit with young people through loss. In doing so we allow young people to be open to what is beyond themselves, namely the Spirit who speaks and guides us into the embrace of our Heavenly Father. The burden of control is not something young people do alone. Jesus invites us to lay down our burdens and discover that we do not have to master our lives in order to receive the gift of Grace.
This cannot be innovated, it’s just a slow patient walk alongside those entrusted to us.
Conclusion
So, returning to our original question, perhaps our desire to promise young people the “best time ever” reveals something of our own desire for control. We want young people to experience something meaningful, to feel something beyond themselves, and to leave with memories that matter. But in promising these things, we risk claiming responsibility for something we cannot manufacture. Things can go wrong, our idea of the “best time” might not be met, and the pressure to create a particular experience can produce anxiety rather than excitement.
Our responsibility is not to manufacture meaning, but to create the conditions in which meaningful experiences might emerge. We can describe what we are offering, provide safe and dependable environments, and give young people the autonomy to decide how they experience what we have planned. And when the unexpected happens, we can resist the urge to control it immediately, choosing instead to respond alongside them. Whether in moments of wonder, joy, disappointment or loss, we offer companionship through the uncontrollability of life.




Comments